Review Guidelines for Curtains Up

  1. This is a website for people who love theatre by people who love theatre
  2. Under no circumstances are there to be any personal attacks on anyone involved in the play, from the playwright to the star or the bartender. No exceptions. The review is of their work, not them.
  3. Whether or not you liked the play is much less important than how you analyse it. I have written a non-scathing review of a play that ended with a commercial even though it goes against my values and was in a rage afterwards. You can too.
  4. We respect the craft of theatre, while also acknowledging that sometimes shows are bad. The focus is on the flaws on the product, not the people who made it
  5. Being critical is encouraged, but that doesn’t mean always being negative. You can and should be just as precise and critical in your positivity
  6. Don’t yuck someone’s yum. Try to acknowledge when something is well crafted but just not a flavour you like. Is it great banana bread and you hate bananas?
  7. Acknowledge your position. If you are seeing an indigenous themed play, acknowledge where you stand. If the topic is something that is sensitive for you, mention in the review. We are humans and our experiences give us a perspective to build from. The only time this is a problem is when you aren’t honest with the reader about your positionality. If you hate puppets, don’t punish a show for using them.
  8. Sincerity matters. You don’t have to like things you feel like you should. Try to figure out what is behind your reaction. I love Bertolt Brecht’s politics but find some of his plays intensely boring